forums
May 21, 2013, 01:35:19 PM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News: 2008-Dec-27: ver 2.50.1 Release available
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register  
Pages: [1]
  Print  
Author Topic: Comparisons with other pda & smart phone Bible s/w appreciated  (Read 2412 times)
Lynn
Administrator
Sr. Member
**
Posts: 595



View Profile Email
« on: October 02, 2008, 02:13:15 AM »

Quote
However until it [BB-Nokia] ever happens I recommend GoBible

I would greatly appreciate feedback on how GoBible and other Bible software for pda's and smart-phones compares to the Berean Bible study freeware (aka BerBible aka BB). Have you used it on a PPC? How about a Palm Treo?

Following are a suggested list to take into account, in the categories of performance, capabilities, and 'other'.
 
Timings: how long does the alternative (GoBible, e-Sword-PPC, etc.) take to:
  • "launch" on the device
  • display a long chapter like Ps 119 or Luke 1
  • input the verse-reference to lookup, or the word(s) for which to search
  • do a 'typical' case-insensitive, all-words search for "Pride fall" (should find several, depending on which translation used)
  • depending on the s/w search flexibility, do a case-sensitive, exact-match, all-words search for "Pride fall" in the range of Old Testament (Should find only Prov 16:18, depending on which translation used. This can be a relatively time-consuming search ... several minutes with some Palm software.)
  • compare the "most complicated" search for which BerBible and the other software can both do to get an "apples and apples" comparison (in general, exact match takes longer, case-insensitive takes longer, entire Bible takes longer,
  • In fairness to GoBible (and other Bible software), BB-PPC has very few "scholarly" capabilities, and negligible "rendering"
  • BerBible-Desktop and BerBible-PPC both have an "oddball" menu-item for "View + Timings (elapsed ms)" to show ... uh ... elapsed milliseconds in the "Find" button.

Capabilities:
  • 'rendering' ... availability of 'tags' such as bold, supescript, highlighting, 'eye-candy', etc.
  • scholarly capabilities (Strongs numbering, CrossRefs, commentaries, FootNotes, dictionary lookups, etc.)
  • resources for free, including modern English Bibles, foreign Bibles, commentaries
  • resources for pay
  • advanced searching (does s/w have more or less flexibility compared to BB, such as range limits, phrase, exact matching, regex, verse-spanning, EXCLUDE, BOOLEAN, etc. BB-PPC has less search flexibility than desktop PC version)
  • split-screen
  • media
  • internationalization ... non-English resources, especially Bibles
  • end-user notes and end-user highlighting (preserved and can be recalled)
  • other capabilities
  • other considerations, like download size, ease-of-use, learning curve, etc.

Other considerations:
  • download size
  • ease-of-use and learning curve
  • ease of installation
  • memory usage and usability from flash-card
  • support
  • how convenient or cumbersome to 'refine' search (limit range, case-sensitive, etc.)
  • whether same resources work on Desktop and smart-device (don't have to pay twice)
  • whether device software 'works-alike' to version for Windows PC desktop (if available) to reduce learning curve .... (i.e. 'desktop replacement')
  • whether 'works-alike' for Linux and/or Mac desktop
  • open source vs closed source (BB is closed source to facilitate publisher permissions)
  • ongoing maintenance ... new releases to 'keep up with the times'
  • reliability .... presence or absence of crashes, hangs, glitches, flaws, etc.
  • other?

Here is a list of "vendors" of which I am aware have Bible software for 'devices' (pda's and smart-phones)
  • Laridian
  • Olive Tree
  • e-Sword for the PPC
  • SwordReader
  • GoBible
  • WORDSearch
  • others?

Here is a list of "platforms" for which Bible software is available:
  • Nokia (used to be 3 different platforms ... maybe more now ... development done in C++)
  • Palm, especially Treo (development done in C++, maybe other languages like micro-Java)
  • BlackBerry (micro-Java)
  • iPhone (? ... Objective-C? ... Object-Pascal? ... my impression is that it is relatively 'closed') ... looked very good for the 2 minute demo I saw
  • Google G1 (C++?)
  • Mobile 5/6 devices without touch-screen and/or QWERTY keyboard (BB-PPC doesn't work on these yet)
  • others

See this post for links to 'animated slideshows' that illustrate BerBible-PPC and BerBible-Palm in use.
http://berbible.org/forums/index.php?topic=3.0

See this link for a FAQ regarding "Other Bible Software". I have always acknowledged that BerBible is not for everyone. Depending on your specific situation, expectations, and requirement, there may well be better 'fits'.)
http://www.berbible.org/faq_other_software.php

See this link for a FAQ regarding "Road Map of Envisioned Enhancements" (primarily related to version for Windows PC desktop)
http://www.berbible.org/faq_roadmap.php
Logged
Pages: [1]
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.7 | SMF © 2006-2008, Simple Machines LLC Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!